One Reason Your D&I Initiatives May Not Be Working
Nov 05, 2020
86 percent of companies have a Diversity and Equal Opportunity (D&EO) policy. But only 11 percent have real, measurable targets. – JUST Capital
We tried to identify the cause of this shocking lag, and unearthed an important observation.
“Over a quarter of employees at large companies do not feel that their direct manager is committed to Diversity and Inclusion (D&I).” – Forbes
The effect trickles across levels. Only 20 percent of respondents say that their organization is at an advanced level or vanguard level in implementing D&I initiatives, according to HR.com.
One respondent to Boston Consulting Group’s (BCG’s) Global Diversity Survey said:
“Our executive team, who is quite removed from our day, openly embraces diversity verbally. However, the people who deal with our employees need to be the ones whose hearts and minds are in this.”
Damage from Disconnect
The same BCG survey also shows that in companies where senior leadership is committed to diversity but managers aren’t:
- Only 65% feel free to be their true selves at work
- Employees are twice as likely to feel excluded
- Employees are thrice more likely to seek employment outside
Having the senior management 100 percent committed to D&I initiatives isn’t enough.
Frontline leaders interact with their teams all day. They are the closest mentors and role models for their reports. They evaluate, promote, communicate, designate, and interact with team members during meetings and therefore play a major role in driving employee experience in the organization.
Frontline managers can implement, neglect, and undermine any change initiative.
This impact is extensive. A Catalyst.org 2019 survey says, “45% of experiences of an inclusive workplace could be explained by “managerial inclusive leadership”.”
How Talent Leaders Can Engage Disengaged Frontline Leaders
So, what must Talent Managers do to encourage frontline leaders? Five actions can greatly help:
#1. Not fad, but a culture
Integrate D&I in the company’s systems through targeted programs and policies. Deloitte has outlined six inclusive character traits: “commitment, collaboration, curiosity, cultural intelligence, courage, and cognizance.”
“One of the things we often say at Deloitte is that being a leader means being an inclusive leader. It’s fundamental to our culture.” – Terri Cooper, Deloitte’s Chief Inclusion Officer
#2. Lead the leaders
Frontline managers make up or influence 80 percent of the workforce. But they get only 20-30 percent of training attention. Talent managers can improve this facet by training frontline leaders in spotting and overcoming unconscious biases.
D&I training programs must be:
- Ongoing, and form a continuous part of leaders’ career development paths.
- Practical, and managers must be able to apply them to day-to-day operations.
Salesforce’s learning solution, TrailHead, includes a module on inclusive leadership practices.
#3. Less Preaching. More Practice
D&I policies must influence everyday workplace interactions. They must lead to authentic conversations, inclusive meetings, and fair work assignments.
Talent leaders need to create an environment in which people can feel free to use their voice.
In team meetings or group discussions, frontline leaders must encourage everyone’s participation. They must rotate roles so underrepresented people or groups don’t get caught up in unattractive roles.
#4. Hack the Hunch
Many frontline leaders resort to gut instincts while arriving at important decisions like plum assignments, promotions, and bonuses. Encourage frontline leaders to use decision-making tools.
#5. Rake the Results
Communicate expectations, and hold managers accountable for results.
The Road Ahead:
D&I is a long-term investment and its savings come in the form of employee retention, commitment, and performance.
A Harvard Business Review study found that teams with inclusive leaders are:
- 17 percent more likely to say they are “high performing”
- 20 percent more likely to make better decisions
- 29 percent more likely to collaborate
Are you engaging your frontline leaders?